‘Transcends incompetence’: Critics blast COP30 compromise deal that omits mention of fossil fuels | CBC News

Brazil’s COP30 presidency pushed through a compromise climate deal on Saturday that would boost finances for poor nations coping with global warming but omitted any mention of the fossil fuels driving it.

In securing the accord, Brazil had attempted to demonstrate global unity in addressing climate change impacts even after the world’s biggest historic emitter, the United States, declined to send an official delegation.

But the agreement, which landed in overtime after two weeks of contentious negotiations in the Amazon city of Belém, exposed deep rifts over how future climate action should be pursued.

After gavelling the deal through, André Corrêa do Lago, president of this year’s conference, acknowledged the talks had been tough.

“We know some of you had greater ambitions for some of the issues at hand,” he said.

WATCH | Protesters disrupt COP30 climate conference:

‘We don’t eat money’: Protesters at COP30 summit in Brazil

The CBC’s international climate correspondent Susan Ormiston explains what happened when protesters stormed the COP30 climate conference in Brazil.

Several countries objected to the summit ending without stronger plans for reining in greenhouse gases or addressing fossil fuels.

Some of the criticism came from Brazil’s neighbours in Latin America, with multiple objections made by Colombia, Panama and Uruguay, before Corrêa do Lago suspended the plenary for further consultations.

Noting that fossil fuels were by far the biggest contributor of planet-warming emissions, Colombia’s negotiator said her country could not go along with a deal that ignored science.

“A consensus imposed under climate denialism is a failed agreement,” the Colombian negotiator said.

The three countries said they objected not to COP30’s overall political deal but to one of the other more technical negotiating texts that countries had been due to approve at the summit’s end, alongside the headline deal.

The three had joined the European Union demanding the agreement include language on a transition away from fossil fuels — while a coalition of countries, including top oil exporter Saudi Arabia, said any mention of fossil fuels was off limits.

After tense overnight negotiations, the EU agreed on Saturday morning not to block a final deal but said it did not agree with the conclusion.

“We should support [the deal] because at least it is going in the right direction,” EU climate commissioner Wopke Hoekstra told reporters before it was sealed.

Panama’s climate negotiator, Juan Carlos Monterrey Gómez, said before the final plenary that his country was not happy with the summit result.

“A climate decision that cannot even say ‘fossil fuels’ is not neutrality, it is complicity. And what is happening here transcends incompetence,” he said.

‘I fear the world still fell short’

The summit also launches a voluntary initiative to speed up climate action to help countries meet their existing pledges to reduce emissions and calls for rich nations to at least triple the amount of money they provide to help developing countries adapt to a warming world by 2035.

Developing countries have argued they urgently need funds to adapt to impacts that are already hitting, like rising sea levels and worsening heat waves, droughts, floods and storms.

Avinash Persaud, special adviser to the president of the Inter-American Development Bank, a multilateral lender focused on Latin America and the Caribbean, said the accord’s focus on finance was important as climate impacts mount.

WATCH | CBC medical columnist on attending COP30:

Canadian doctor at COP30 climate summit in Brazil

The COP30 climate summit is wrapping in Brazil on Nov. 18. It opened in the city of Belém to protests and controversy. On the eve of the climate summit, Brazil’s government green-lit gas giant Petrobras’ plan to begin oil exploration near the mouth of the Amazon River. In Canada, Carney’s government has fast-tracked a number of oil and energy projects. It’s against this backdrop that CBC’s medical columnist Dr. Melissa Lem joins us from Brazil.

“But I fear the world still fell short on more rapid-release grants for developing countries responding to loss and damage. That goal is as urgent as it is hard,” Persaud said.

Several countries including Sierra Leone also objected at the final plenary to a watering down of what they should be measuring in areas such as food security in order to prepare for climate impacts.

The delegate from Sierra Leone said the list of indicators agreed “is not the list crafted by experts and is not a list that clearly tells our story.”

“Instead, we leave COP with indicators that are unclear, unmeasurable, and in many cases, unusable. So we must ask ourselves, how are we helping the most vulnerable if this is the quality of the outcomes we call ambition?” Jiwoh Emmanuel Abdulai, Sierra Leone’s climate minister, said.

EU, Arab group at odds over fossil fuels

The overnight impasse between the European Union and the Arab group of nations over fossil fuels had pushed the talks past a Friday deadline, triggering all-night negotiations before a compromise could be reached.

Corrêa do Lago, COP30’s president, said on Saturday morning that the presidency was issuing a side text on fossil fuels — as well as on protecting forests — keeping it out of the main accord because of the lack of consensus.

But he urged countries to keep discussing the issues.

Saturday’s agreement also launches a process for climate bodies to review how to align international trade with climate action, according to the deal text, amid concerns that rising trade barriers are limiting the adoption of clean technology.