Saudi Arabia Oil Transition: Vision 2030’s Challenge | Shale Magazine

For nearly a decade, Saudi Arabia’s Vision 2030 has embodied a pivotal shift from hydrocarbons toward mega projects, renewable energy sources, tourism, and industry. While the vision is intended to usher in a new post-oil era for Saudi Arabia, the dependence on oil for the region is far from over. 

Despite undeniable progress on the goals of Vision 2030, oil dependence remains firmly entrenched in Saudi Arabia’s economy. Deep-seated structural and economic realities are casting a vast shadow over plans to part ways with oil dependence and its fluctuating economic challenges. 

The Vision VS. The Numbers

In 2016, Saudi Arabia announced its ambitious plan to diversify its economy, social structure, and cultural composition. The plan aligned with the ambitions of the Crown Prince and Prime Minister, Mohammed bin Salmam, to reduce the kingdom’s overwhelming oil dependence. 

The Crown Prince has been at the forefront of the charge to shape the vision into reality for the kingdom. His leadership drove the Saudi Arabian government to launch the initiative with its ambitious reforms, economic diversification, social liberalization, and massive infrastructure projects. The multi-faceted approach, though ambitious, sought to relieve some of the financial fluctuations of an oil-dependent state. 

Despite making significant strides towards becoming less oil-dependent, the Arab nation is far from reducing its reliance on hydrocarbons. In fact, the key indicators allude to a potentially greater dependence on oil than before the 2016 announcement. 

According to Bloomberg, oil still provides the Saudis about 60% of government revenue and around 65% of the exports, which is roughly the same as 2016. In order to balance its budget, the Saudi Arabian government needs a higher fiscal breakeven than in previous years. In 2025, the kingdom needs barrel prices of $96 to make ends meet, or $113 if Public Investment Fund (PIF) spending is included. 

Mega Building Projects Funded By Oil and Vulnerable to Oil Prices

At the forefront of Saudi Arabia’s Vision 2030 projects are massive initiatives, like the $500 billion NEOM megacity, the Red Sea tourism development, and the Diriya Heritage Revival. These symbols of the Gulf kingdom’s economic diversification derive their funding directly and indirectly from oil revenue, leaving them vulnerable to fluctuating costs and the high break-even point for the nation’s budget. 

While Saudi Arabia moves forward with diversification, a paradox of funding unfolds. The flagships of the nation’s post-oil initiatives are tethered mainly to the commodity they seek to outpace. This symbiotic relationship between oil and the mega projects presents potential funding fluctuations, progress disruptions, and potentially detrimental conflicts down the road. 

While Saudi Arabia has tapped into debt markets to maintain its momentum for these massive undertakings, global interest rates and wary investors toward mega-projects could add additional pressure, potentially leading to progress delays and funding issues. 

The Saudi Arabian government seems to be in a vicious cycle: the more money needed for diversification, the more the Kingdom relies on oil exports to provide it. This means that for Vision 2030, market volatility could be a significant detriment to Saudi Arabia’s timeline. 

The State of Renewables in Saudi Arabia 

Included in the massive mega projects is a significant interest in developing and progressing Saudi Arabia’s renewable energy program. While on paper, the Gulf kingdom claims it will have renewable energy resources make up 50% of its energy mix, progress towards that goal has been slow. 

According to Ember Energy, renewable energy accounted for approximately 1% of Saudi Arabia’s Energy Mix as of 2023. Saudi Arabia generated 452 terawatt hours of electricity in 2023, with 62% from natural gas, 38% from oil, and a negligible amount from renewables. Currently, the solar farms remain small-scale compared to the vast conception needed of a rapidly urbanizing population, energy-hungry mega-projects, and enormous AI data centers.

Part of the problem is that oil remains cheap to produce domestically, making it politically and financially advantageous to burn for electricity in the short term. Renewable projects, on the other hand, require large-scale infrastructure, investment, and specialized knowledge. These requirements directly compete with other diversification projects for resources and personnel. 

In order for Saudi Arabia’s renewable energy infrastructure to take off, grid capacity, storage infrastructure, and private sector involvement must scale up dramatically. However, at the current standing, oil and gas will continue to dominate the Saudi energy mix far beyond 2030.  

Structural Obstacles and Governance Realities 

A major obstacle preventing Saudi Arabia from reaching its original goals by 2030 is the entrenched systems that favor oil as the nation’s primary economic engine. Dismantling these systems presents a massive challenge to the state, financially, industrially, and infrastructurally. The public sector in Saudi Arabia relies heavily on government jobs tied to oil revenue, which further complicates the process of detangling oil reliance. 

Government subsidies, which are a long-standing feature of the Saudi social construct, keep domestic fuel artificially low. While past attempts have been made at subsidy reform, abrupt spikes in fuel prices have resulted in public backlash and given pause to the Saudi government from further advancing significant reforms. 

The Resiliency of Oil & Gas

While Saudi Arabia’s Vision 2030 is certainly ambitious, the remaining resilience of gas and oil means it is far from disappearing and may well remain in effect into the 2030s, particularly in developing economies. As Saudi Arabia holds a competitive advantage as one of the lowest-cost producers globally, its strategic output is set to influence the global markets.

Despite its progress towards economic diversification, Saudi Arabia continues to enhance its hydrocarbon capacity, and plans to continue production seem uninterrupted. In the meantime, the mining, industry, and construction sectors are growing, but not enough to offset oil’s domination. 

Stay In The Know with Shale

While the world transitions, you can count on Shale Magazine to bring me the latest intel and insight. Our reporters uncover the sources and stories you need to know in the worlds of finance, sustainability, and investment.

Subscribe to Shale Magazine to stay informed about the happenings that impact your world. Or listen to our critically acclaimed podcast, Energy Mixx Radio Show, where we interview some of the most interesting people, thought leaders, and influencers in the wide world of energy.

Subscribe to get more posts from Jess Henley