‘Reckless and dangerous’: Florida to eliminate childhood vaccine mandates in schools | CBC News

Florida plans to become the first state to eliminate vaccine mandates that have been a cornerstone of public health policy for decades in keeping schoolchildren and adults safe from infectious diseases.   

State Surgeon General Dr. Joseph Ladapo, who announced the decision Wednesday, cast current requirements in schools and elsewhere as “immoral” intrusions on people’s rights that hamper parents’ ability to make health decisions for their children.

“People have a right to make their own decisions, informed decisions,” Ladapo, who has frequently clashed with the medical establishment, said at a news conference in Valrico. “They don’t have the right to tell you what to put in your body. Take it away from them.”

Physician groups and other health organizations have long considered vaccines to be safe and the most effective way to stop the spread of communicable diseases, especially among schoolchildren.   

Dr. Rana Alissa, chair of the Florida Chapter of the American Academy of Pediatrics, said removing vaccines puts students and school staff at greater risk.

“When everyone in a school is vaccinated, it is harder for diseases to spread and easier for everyone to continue learning and having fun,” Alissa said in an email. “When children are sick and miss school, caregivers also miss work, which not only impacts those families but also the local economy.”   

Democratic state Rep. Anna Eskamani, who is running for mayor of Orlando, said in a social media post that scrapping vaccines “is reckless and dangerous” and could cause outbreaks of preventable disease.   

“This is a public health disaster in the making for the Sunshine State,” Eskamani said on the social platform X.   

In Florida, vaccine mandates for child daycare facilities and public schools include shots for measles, chickenpox, hepatitis B, diphtheria-tetanus-acellular pertussis, polio and other diseases, according to the state Health Department’s website.

The department, Ladapo said, can scrap its own rules for some vaccine mandates, but others would require action by the Florida Legislature. He did not specify any particular vaccines but repeated several times the effort would end “all of them. Every last one of them.”

‘Dismantling of public health’

The move comes as the Trump administration works to restructure and downsize the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) and advance anti-vaccine policies championed by Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr., which are contradicted by decades of scientific research. 

The rise in anti-vaccine sentiment has coincided with a resurgence of measles in the U.S., with more than 1,400 cases recorded so far nationally, according to the CDC, the highest number of yearly cases in more than 30 years. 

The Democratic governors of Washington, Oregon and California announced Wednesday that they created an alliance to safeguard health policies, contending that the administration is politicizing public health decisions.   

The partnership plans to co-ordinate health guidelines by aligning immunization plans based on recommendations from respected national medical organizations, according to a joint statement from Gov. Bob Ferguson of Washington, Gov. Tina Kotek of Oregon and Gov. Gavin Newsom of California.   

“The dismantling of public health and dismissal of experienced and respected health leaders and advisers, along with the lack of using science, data, and evidence to improve our nation’s health are placing lives at risk,” California state health officer Erica Pan said in the news release.

Other attempts by scientists and health experts to combat the erosion of public health in the U.S. have seen success this week. On Wednesday the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services agreed to restore health and science-related webpages and data as part of a lawsuit settlement with doctors groups and other organizations who sued.

Washington State Medical Association, along with other groups, had sued after federal health officials deleted or removed information on a range of topics including pregnancy risks, opioid-use disorder and the AIDS epidemic in response to a Trump executive order that told agencies to stop using the term “gender” in federal policies and documents. 

It was an “egregious example of government overreach,” said Dr. John Bramhall, the organization’s president, in a statement.

More than 100 websites and resources will be restored to the state they were in, according to the Washington State Medical Association. 

Under Republican Gov. Ron DeSantis, Florida resisted imposing COVID vaccines on schoolchildren during the pandemic, requiring “passports” for places that draw crowds, as well as school closures and mandates that workers get the shots to keep their jobs.

“I don’t think there’s another state that’s done as much as Florida. We want to stay ahead of the curve,” the governor said.   

DeSantis also announced on Wednesday the creation of a state “Make America Healthy Again” commission modelled after similar initiatives established at the federal level by Kennedy.

The commission would look into such things as allowing informed consent in medical matters, promoting safe and nutritious food, boosting parental rights in medical decisions about their children and eliminating what DeSantis called “medical orthodoxy that is not supported by the data.” The commission will be chaired by Lt. Gov. Jay Collins and Florida first lady Casey DeSantis.