More than a dozen Labour MPs have expressed criticism of the government’s radical reforms to Britain’s asylum system.
Shabana Mahmood has proposed sweeping new reforms to the UK asylum system today, which has quickly led to a visceral backlash from many Labour figures.
Modelled on Denmark’s tough immigration rules, the new measures could see fast-tracked deportations, and a quadrupling of the time it might take to achieve permanent status.
Mahmood described the plans as the “most sweeping asylum reforms in modern times” and said the government is building an asylum system “fit for the world as it is”.
It’s prompted a fierce debate within the party, with many Labour MPs quick to express their horror at the perceived draconian measures.
However, other Labour figures such as Hartlepool MP Jonathan Brash and Peterborough MP Andrew Pakes have indicated their support.
Speaking to the BBC, asylum minister Alex Norris defended the measures and said the “fair and humane” plans would “restore order and control at our borders”.
Here is LabourList’s tracker of which MPs have made their disapproval known:
Tony Vaughan
The new MP for Folkestone and Hythe was among the first to make their displeasure at the new proposals clear. His post has now become totemic in opposition to the government’s harsh new measures.
He posted on X: “The idea that recognised refugees need to be deported is wrong. We absolutely need immigration controls. And where those controls decide to grant asylum, we should welcome and integrate, not create perpetual limbo and alienation.”
The Prime Minister said in September that we are at a fork in the road. These asylum proposals suggest we have taken the wrong turning.
The idea that recognised refugees need to be deported is wrong. We absolutely need immigration controls. And where those controls decide to…
— Tony Vaughan KC MP (@tonyvaughanMP) November 16, 2025
Several other Labour MPs have shared Vaughan’s remarks including Clive Lewis, Bell Ribeiro-Addy, Kate Osborne, Olivia Blake and Peter Lamb.
Nadia Whittome
Nottingham East MP Nadia Whittome hit out at the Home Secretary’s proposals in the House of Commons, describing the proposed reforms as “dystopian”.
She said: “It’s shameful that a Labour government is ripping up the rights and protections of people who have endured unimaginable trauma.”
John McDonnell
Veteran left winger John McDonnell responded to Vaughan’s original post, making clear his own opposition to the reforms.
He said: “Tony Vaughan is one of the new MPs elected for Labour last year & in his contributions to Commons debates has displayed a considered approach to issues. He’s certainly not what the media would call a ‘usual suspect.’
“I suspect he is reflecting here what many in the PLP feel.”
Sheffield Central MP Abtisam Mohamed also replies to the original post by Vaughan.
She said: “If we truly want an asylum system that works, the answer is clear: faster decisions, better accommodation, and a functioning agreement with France. Punishing recognised refugees won’t achieve any of that.
“We need a fair, workable approach, not another round of policies that divide communities and fail on their own terms.”
Stella Creasy
In an op-ed in The Guardian today, Creasy blasted the government’s Denmark-style approach to asylum.
She wrote: “This is not just performatively cruel, it’s economically misjudged. There is scant evidence that Denmark’s decision to refuse to grant longterm asylum to most has deterred anyone who would have chosen Denmark as a destination.”
Long-standing member of Labour’s national executive committee Ann Black echoed Creasy’s concerns and said: “I’m with Stella on this” in a post on social media.
Simon Opher
The Stroud MP said: “We should stop the scapegoating of immigrants because it’s wrong and cruel … we should push back on the racist agenda of Reform rather than echo it.”
Brian Leishman
The Alloa and Grangemouth MP, who recently got the Labour whip back, has told The New Statesman’s Megan Kenyon that he has “reservations” about the new measures.
He said: “We need to build a caring compassionate society that looks after people from the UK and also from other countries. And that needs to be done with real Labour Party values.”
Sarah Owen
The Luton North MP posted on BlueSky: “A strong immigration system doesn’t need to be a cruel one. It shouldn’t need saying – but refugees & asylum seekers are real people, fleeing war and persecution.”
Cat Eccles
Stourbridge MP Cat Eccles told PoliticsHome’s Harriet Symonds: “I’m massively disappointed and angry about what the Home Sec is saying.”
Rachael Maskell
MP for York Central Rachael Maskell criticised the proposals in an interview with Times Radio and said: “The dehumanisation of people in desperation is the antithesis of what the Labour Party is about.”
Richard Burgon
MP for Leeds East Richard Burgon described the plans as “morally wrong [and] politically disastrous” in a post on social media.
He said: “We’ve moved a long way from the days when the Prime Minister promised “an immigration system based on compassion and dignity.” We now have policies and briefings that seem to have been dragged from the moral sewer – and that are even being celebrated by far-right figures like ‘Tommy Robinson’.
“Labour voters who have abandoned the party will not be won back by this. They haven’t flocked to Reform but mainly to other progressive parties or now simply say they don’t know who to vote for. Many who have stuck with Labour so far will be repulsed by these attacks on vulnerable people fleeing war and persecution.”
Ian Byrne
MP for Liverpool West Derby Ian Byrne also criticised the government’s planned asylum system reforms and accused the Prime Minister of drifting “far from [his] promise of ‘compassion and dignity’, towards policies dragged from the moral abyss and applauded by far-right figures like Farage & Yaxley-Lennon”.
Today, the Government will make yet another desperate bid to outflank Reform on asylum seekers.
We’ve drifted far from the PM’s promise of ‘compassion and dignity’, towards policies dragged from the moral abyss and applauded by far-right figures like Farage & Yaxley-Lennon.…
— lan Byrne MP (@IanByrneMP) November 17, 2025
Andy McDonald
Middlesborough and Thornaby East MP Andy McDonald has urged the government to withdraw the proposed asylum policies, reportedly calling them “cruel, unfair and unworkable”.
Subscribe here to our daily newsletter roundup of Labour news, analysis and comment– and follow us on Bluesky, WhatsApp, X and Facebook.
Share your thoughts. Contribute on this story or tell your own by writing to our Editor. The best letters every week will be published on the site. Find out how to get your letter published.
- SHARE: If you have anything to share that we should be looking into or publishing about this story – or any other topic involving Labour– contact us (strictly anonymously if you wish) at [email protected].
- SUBSCRIBE: Sign up to LabourList’s morning email here for the best briefing on everything Labour, every weekday morning.
- DONATE: If you value our work, please chip in a few pounds a week and become one of our supporters, helping sustain and expand our coverage.
- PARTNER: If you or your organisation might be interested in partnering with us on sponsored events or projects, email [email protected].
- ADVERTISE: If your organisation would like to advertise or run sponsored pieces on LabourList‘s daily newsletter or website, contact our exclusive ad partners Total Politics at [email protected].
labourlist.org (Article Sourced Website)
#Asylum #reform #Full #list #MPs #opposing #governments #immigration #proposals #LabourList