10 Overhyped Islands Americans Name Most – Author Kathy Haan

We may earn money or products from the companies mentioned in this post. This means if you click on the link and purchase the item, I will receive a small commission at no extra cost to you … you’re just helping re-supply our family’s travel fund.

Here’s the thing: you book that island getaway expecting the white-sanded beach or emerald lagoon of your Instagram dreams and you get something far less magical. You may still have a nice time, but if you’ve built up high expectations, you risk being underwhelmed. These ten islands are often named by Americans as must-visits, yet many travelers walk away feeling they paid for the photo more than the experience. The point isn’t to bash them; it’s to help you decide what’s really worth your time and money.

1. Santorini, Greece

Santorini’s cliffside villages and blue-domed churches are beautiful, no doubt, but you’ll be sharing that postcard view with thousands of tourists every day. The crowds are intense, the prices steep, and the infrastructure strained from the surge of cruise ships. Even getting a quiet dinner with a view can mean waiting in line or paying a premium. If you know you’re going for the iconic view and not solitude, fine but don’t expect peace, quiet, or affordability. Santorini is breathtaking, but also overcrowded and oversold.

2. Mykonos, Greece

Mykonos has earned its glamorous reputation, but the reality often feels more like a playground for the wealthy than a relaxed Greek island escape. Prices for food, drinks, and accommodation are some of the highest in the country, and the narrow streets are packed during peak season. The beaches are pretty, but many are dominated by expensive clubs and thumping music. If your idea of fun is high-end nightlife and celebrity-spotting, you’ll fit right in. But if you’re craving culture and quiet, Mykonos might leave you cold.

3. Bali, Indonesia

Bali still has temples, rice terraces, and beautiful beaches; but it’s not the untouched paradise many expect. Overtourism has hit hard: traffic jams, pollution, and higher costs now define much of the experience, especially in Canggu and Seminyak. You’ll still find charm in the smaller villages or northern areas, but it takes effort. If you go knowing that it’s busy and commercial, you’ll still enjoy it. If you’re dreaming of peace and pristine beaches, prepare for a reality check that comes with a crowd.

4. Aruba, Caribbean

Aruba markets itself as “one happy island,” but the heavy resort presence and steep prices can leave you feeling you’ve overpaid for sunshine. Many beaches are beautiful yet busy, lined with hotels that make it hard to find an authentic or quiet spot. Food and excursions often cost far more than expected, and the sense of adventure some travelers seek just isn’t there. Aruba isn’t bad; it’s just more predictable than magical. Great for luxury seekers, less so for travelers craving discovery.

5. Phuket, Thailand

Phuket used to be a tropical paradise, but years of development have turned large parts of it into a crowded resort hub. Patong Beach, once famous for its beauty, now feels more like a neon carnival with constant noise and traffic. While there are quieter corners and stunning viewpoints, most of the island feels busy and commercial. If you go, choose smaller beaches away from the main tourist zones or visit off-season. Otherwise, you might wonder what happened to the Thailand everyone talked about.

6. Maui, Hawai‘i (USA)

Maui’s landscapes are incredible lush valleys, waterfalls, volcanic craters but the island’s popularity means high prices and traffic jams are now part of the deal. Hotel rates and rental cars are some of the most expensive in the U.S., and beaches can be packed during peak months. You’ll still find beauty, but the sense of serenity that used to define the island is harder to catch. If you go expecting convenience and comfort, you’ll enjoy it. If you’re after quiet or budget travel, it’s not the place.

7. The Maldives

The Maldives looks unreal in photos – crystal lagoons, overwater villas, total privacy; but the truth is more complicated. Each resort sits on its own tiny island, and almost everything costs extra, from meals to transfers. Once you’re there, you’re basically stuck with whatever your resort offers, which can feel limiting. It’s undeniably beautiful, but also heavily commercialized and very expensive. Go if you want luxury and isolation, but skip it if you’re looking for culture or variety in your travel experience.

8. Bora Bora, French Polynesia

Bora Bora sells itself as the ultimate romantic escape, but what you’re really paying for is exclusivity. The water is dazzling, but nearly every inch of the island caters to luxury travelers. Affordable accommodations are rare, and activities outside the resorts are limited. You’ll spend more time within a resort bubble than experiencing local life. It’s an amazing once-in-a-lifetime spot; if you’re okay spending a small fortune for postcard-perfect scenery. For most travelers, there are cheaper islands that offer the same beauty.

9. Ibiza, Spain

Ibiza’s party reputation is deserved, but that’s exactly the problem; it overshadows everything else. The island’s quiet beaches and villages exist, but they’re hard to enjoy when the rest of the island feels dominated by nightlife, expensive clubs, and tourists chasing the next big party. If you go for the music and energy, you’ll have a blast. But if you’re imagining long, peaceful swims and a taste of local life, Ibiza might frustrate you. It’s fun but exhausting, and definitely not for everyone.

10. Koh Samui, Thailand

Koh Samui’s postcard beaches and luxury resorts attract crowds that have reshaped the island. The once laid-back vibe now feels busier, with congested roads and beaches lined with sunbeds and bars. Many travelers still enjoy it, but it’s far from the untouched paradise people imagine. If you’re after nightlife, spa resorts, and convenience, it works. But if you’re chasing a sense of escape, you might find more peace on smaller Thai islands nearby. The charm’s there; it’s just buried under the tourism boom.

Other Blog Posts You Might Enjoy