The Best Cashmere Sweaters Under $200

The following content may contain affiliate links. When you click and shop the links, we receive a commission.

Since I have sensitive skin, most sweaters make me itch like crazy. Even the tiniest bit of wool – like, a whisper – and I’m miserable all day, but I know (and love) that cashmere never irritates my skin. And there’s just something special about slipping into a cashmere sweater that feels so elevated. It makes jeans feel more polished and like I actually have my life together. 

At 41 years old, I’m at the stage where I want to invest in quality pieces that actually last. But with two young boys, I’m also realistic – I’m not wearing $600 cashmere while going to the park. I want sweaters that feel luxurious, don’t itch, but don’t make me panic if someone wipes peanut butter on my sleeve. After years of testing (and a lot of returns), these are the best cashmere sweaters under $200 – beautifully made, soft enough for sensitive skin, and durable enough for real life.

The Best Cashmere Sweaters Under $200

Quince

If you’re looking for the best quality-to-price ratio, Quince is hard to beat. Their Grade-A Mongolian cashmere feels just as soft as pieces from designer brands like Jenni Kayne or Brochu Walker, at a fraction of the price.

I own both the Quince Mongolian Cashmere Crewneck Sweater and the Cashmere V-Neck Sweater, and both have held up beautifully over multiple seasons. They’re machine-washable (a huge perk), come in a wide variety of colors from ivory to camel to navy, and the fit is consistently flattering.

They do tend to run a bit relaxed, so if you want a more fitted look, size down. For that effortless, slightly oversized feel, go true to size. At around $50–$100, Quince is a perfect spot to grab affordable cashmere.

(Here’s my full Quince review if you want to order anything else.)

Madewell

Madewell’s cashmere is the perfect bridge between budget and luxury. Their Cashmere Sweater Tees and V-Neck Sweaters are soft without being too delicate, and they have a relaxed yet intentional fit that flatters.

I especially love the striped versions – they look chic with high-rise jeans or a wool midi skirt. Madewell also tends to offer fun seasonal shades alongside classics like navy, camel, and heather gray.

Sustainability is a bonus: their recycled cashmere reduces waste without sacrificing the cozy factor.

(These are my favorite Madewell jeans, if that’s helpful.)

Splendid

Splendid cashmere has that California-luxe vibe that is relaxed, slightly slouchy, and impossibly soft. Their cashmere-blend styles drape beautifully and feel featherlight, making them perfect for layering under coats or tucking into wide-leg trousers. I just ordered the Cashmere Polo Sweater and the Cashmere Turtleneck Tank, which both layer beautifully.

I love that Splendid leans into soft, creamy tones (like ivory and tan) that go with everything. Their silhouettes aren’t bulky, so they layer easily under your favorite trench or blazer. They also have more styles than the standard ones that Quince carries. 

Expect to spend around $150–$200, depending on the style.

Abercrombie

If you haven’t tried Abercrombie in a while, their sweaters are worth another look. Their cashmere sweaters are incredibly soft, come in modern cuts, and have that just-right oversized drape that works with everything from jeans to midi skirts.

I especially love their Cashmere mockneck sweater, sweater shell top, and cashmere V-neck sweater. I also just bought the short-sleeve cashmere sweater to compare to Quince and prefer the slightly longer sleeves on Abercrombie’s version, but that’s just personal preference. 

I love Abercrombie for everyday wear – these sweaters feel elevated but approachable, perfect for a cozy coffee run or casual Friday.

And if you haven’t tried their denim yet, you’re missing out. I rounded up my favorite Abercrombie jeans here.

Tuckernuck

If your style leans classic or preppy like mine, Tuckernuck’s cashmere collection will speak your language. Their Cashmere Tees, Cashmere Cardigans, and Cashmere Crewnecks are some of my favorite pieces I’ve seen them release this season (all just under $200), and I can’t wait to get my hands on them.

They’re structured enough to hold their shape, thick enough to feel substantial, and polished enough for both office days and weekends. I especially love their palette – rich navy, camel, and cream –  that pairs beautifully with tailored trousers or jeans.

These are investment pieces that feel truly special without crossing into four-figure territory. Most styles land between $180 – $250.

Everlane

This brand’s approach to cashmere is minimalist and intentional, and tey’re known for transparency (both in terms of materials and production).

Everlane’s grade-A cashmere sweaters are soft, smooth, and made for layering. I especially love the Cashmere Cropped High-V and Cashmere Polo for a modern twist. The fit is tailored but not tight, which makes them easy to dress up or down.

The neutral palette (cream, camel, gray, black) makes Everlane pieces perfect for capsule wardrobes or anyone who values simplicity and quality.

Aritzia

Aritzia’s in-house brands like Wilfred and Babaton have become go-tos for modern, feminine cashmere. Their pieces often feature drop shoulders, cropped lengths, and refined silhouettes that feel fresh without being trendy.

The Bare Cashmere Crew Sweater and Bare Cashmere Crew Cardigan are two standout styles. They drape beautifully, layer effortlessly, and look great with both jeans and tailored trousers.

At $150–$200, Aritzia cashmere feels indulgent but attainable — ideal for when you want something a little more fashion-forward.

Why is Cashmere So Expensive?

It’s easy to wonder why some cashmere sweaters cost $600 while others cost $100. The short version? It comes down to the quality and sourcing of the fibers.

Cashmere comes from the soft undercoat of cashmere goats, typically in Mongolia or China. Each goat produces only a few ounces of usable fiber per year, which is why it’s such a rare and coveted material.

Grades matter:

• Grade A fibers are the finest and longest, producing ultra-soft, lightweight sweaters that resist pilling.
• Grade B or C fibers are thicker and coarser, often used in blends or lower-cost pieces.

Luxury brands like Jenni Kayne and Brochu Walker use the very finest grades and hand-finished construction, which drives up the cost. But mid-range brands like Quince and Tuckernuck use excellent quality yarns that deliver 90% of the luxury feel without the luxury markup.

Care tip: Always hand-wash or use a delicate cycle in a mesh bag, lay flat to dry, and use a sweater comb to remove pills. Treat it right, and your cashmere will last for years.

Final Thoughts

Cashmere doesn’t have to be a splurge-only fabric. With the right brands, you can build a wardrobe full of timeless, ultra-soft pieces without spending a fortune.

Here’s a quick breakdown:

If you have sensitive skin like me, cashmere is worth every penny: no itch, no irritation, just softness you’ll actually want to live in. Start with versatile neutrals like ivory, camel, and navy (the ones that pair effortlessly with denim, trousers, or skirts) and add a striped or oversized version for variety.

Because at the end of the day, I want my closet to be full of pieces that feel good, look timeless, and can survive two little boys climbing all over me. These sweaters check all the boxes – luxe without being precious, and classic enough to wear for years.

Other Posts You Might Like:

Shop The Post