13 Secret Islands in America You Can Actually Visit – Idyllic Pursuit

We may earn money or products from the companies mentioned in this post. This means if you click on the link and purchase the item, I will receive a small commission at no extra cost to you … you’re just helping re-supply our family’s travel fund.

When people think of islands in the United States, the same names often come up, but there are plenty of lesser-known spots worth exploring. Tucked into bays, rivers, and remote coastlines, these hidden islands are destinations where you can escape the noise and feel like you’ve uncovered something special. Some are rustic and wild, while others have history, quirky communities, or pristine beaches that rival popular tourist hubs. What unites them all is the sense of discovery. These thirteen secret islands prove you don’t need to leave the country to find an adventure that feels completely new.

1. Sapelo Island, Georgia

Accessible only by ferry, Sapelo Island is a blend of untouched nature and deep cultural history. Fewer than a hundred residents live here, many descendants of the Gullah-Geechee community. Visitors can explore quiet beaches, salt marshes, and the historic Reynolds Mansion. Wildlife thrives, from armadillos to sea turtles, making it perfect for nature lovers. The limited access means crowds are rare, so you can enjoy a sense of solitude while learning about the island’s unique heritage.

2. Whidbey Island, Washington

Just a short drive and ferry ride from Seattle, Whidbey Island feels worlds away. Known for its rolling farmland, coastal bluffs, and charming small towns, it’s a mix of natural beauty and culture. Ebey’s Landing National Historical Reserve offers incredible hikes, while Coupeville provides historic charm and fresh seafood. The island is big enough for exploration but quiet enough to feel like a true retreat. It’s a spot where beaches meet artistry and small-town living.

3. Block Island, Rhode Island

Block Island sits off the coast of Rhode Island, often overshadowed by nearby Martha’s Vineyard and Nantucket. Its dramatic bluffs, 17 miles of beaches, and quaint downtown make it a hidden jewel. The island is ideal for biking, with scenic roads leading to lighthouses and panoramic ocean views. Birdwatchers flock here during migration seasons, and the island’s laid-back vibe makes it a slower, calmer alternative to more crowded destinations.

4. Cumberland Island, Georgia

Cumberland Island is a national seashore where wild horses roam the dunes and centuries-old ruins tell stories of the past. Accessible only by ferry, it offers primitive camping, long stretches of empty beaches, and trails through maritime forests. The island once hosted Carnegie family estates, and their remnants still stand. With no cars and limited development, it feels like stepping back in time. Visitors can truly disconnect here, making it one of the most unspoiled islands on the East Coast.

5. Tangier Island, Virginia

Sitting in the Chesapeake Bay, Tangier Island is known for its crabbing culture and isolated charm. The island’s residents speak in a distinct accent, rooted in centuries of heritage. Biking is the main way to get around, and fresh seafood is a highlight of any visit. Rising sea levels threaten its future, making it a place to experience while you still can. A trip here feels like stepping into a living history lesson, set against the backdrop of bay waters.

6. Santa Catalina Island, California

Though close to Los Angeles, Catalina feels like a secret escape once you step off the ferry. Avalon offers a lively harbor town, while Two Harbors is rustic and remote. Activities range from snorkeling in clear waters to zip-lining above the island. Bison, introduced decades ago, still roam the hills. With sunny weather and endless outdoor activities, Catalina balances adventure and relaxation. Despite its proximity to the mainland, it feels like a destination all its own.

7. Mackinac Island, Michigan

Mackinac Island, set in Lake Huron, is best known for banning cars. Horse-drawn carriages and bicycles are the main ways to get around, giving the island a timeless feel. Visitors can explore historic forts, Victorian architecture, and scenic trails. Famous for its fudge, the island also offers sweeping views of the Great Lakes. The lack of modern traffic makes it both peaceful and nostalgic, a place that blends charm with natural beauty.

8. Lopez Island, Washington

Part of the San Juan Islands, Lopez is the most laid-back of the group. Cyclists love its gentle terrain and welcoming vibe from locals, often called “the friendly isle.” Beaches, quiet coves, and small farms dot the landscape. It’s less crowded than Orcas or San Juan Island, making it ideal for those seeking a slower pace. The island’s simplicity is its charm, offering relaxation without sacrificing natural beauty.

9. Jekyll Island, Georgia

Once an exclusive retreat for America’s wealthiest families, Jekyll Island is now open to everyone, yet it retains a sense of quiet luxury. Driftwood Beach, with its hauntingly beautiful fallen trees, is a must-see. Historic cottages, biking paths, and wide-open beaches make it a versatile destination. Limited development helps preserve its peaceful atmosphere, while its history adds a layer of intrigue. It’s one of Georgia’s most photogenic and memorable islands.

10. Daufuskie Island, South Carolina

Accessible only by ferry or private boat, Daufuskie Island is a step into the past. Dirt roads, historic churches, and an artsy community give it character. The island has Gullah heritage sites, quiet beaches, and local artisans who showcase crafts. With no bridge connection, it has retained a raw, authentic atmosphere. Visitors come for the sense of isolation, paired with opportunities to learn about culture and history in a unique setting.

11. Shackleford Banks, North Carolina

Part of the Cape Lookout National Seashore, Shackleford Banks is best known for its wild horses roaming the beaches. Accessible only by boat, it offers a raw, untouched coastal experience. Visitors can camp, fish, or simply enjoy the empty shoreline. It’s also a prime spot for shell collecting. With no development, it feels like a true wilderness escape, where the natural world is the main attraction.

12. Fire Island, New York

Despite being close to New York City, Fire Island feels like another world. Known for its car-free villages, lively boardwalks, and wide beaches, it’s a mix of nature and community spirit. The island has long been a haven for artists and the LGBTQ+ community, giving it a vibrant culture. Whether you’re there to relax on the sand or join the nightlife, Fire Island delivers an experience unlike anywhere else on the East Coast.

13. Vieques, Puerto Rico

Though technically not a state, Puerto Rico is part of the U.S., and Vieques is one of its most dazzling islands. It’s famous for Mosquito Bay, the brightest bioluminescent bay in the world. Pristine beaches, wild horses, and a relaxed pace define the island. It’s less crowded than mainland Puerto Rican destinations, making it feel secretive despite its beauty. Vieques combines natural wonder with laid-back charm, perfect for travelers looking to escape the ordinary.

Other Blog Posts You Might Enjoy