Love and Other Paradoxes Review: A Time-Travel Romance That Defies Destiny – Beauty Cooks Kisses

Sometimes, the most captivating stories are those that dare to bend the rules of reality, and my Love and Other Paradoxes review will explore how Catriona Silvey’s novel does just that. This time travel romance pulls you into the life of Joe Greene, a poet struggling to find his voice in the hallowed halls of Cambridge, until a chance encounter in a coffee shop will throw his entire future into question. My review will delve into the enchanting and often paradoxical relationship that develops between Joe and the enigmatic Esi, a character who forces him (and the reader) to consider whether love can truly transcend the constraints of time itself.

Disclaimer: Some links found on this page might be affiliate links. If you click an affiliate link and make a purchase, we may earn a commission. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

A Time-Traveling Twist on Romantic Destiny

Joe Greene is wrestling with his writing searching for the spark that will ignite his verse. His days are filled with more frustration than inspiration, a stark contrast to the literary giant he unknowingly is in the future. It’s during one of these wordless wanderings that a unique coffee shop window catches his eye, leading to an encounter that will irrevocably alter his path.

Working at the shop is Esi, a captivating barista with an air of knowing mystery and a tendency to utter puzzling pronouncements. Their initial exchange, filled with cryptic hints about Joe’s future, sparks an undeniable curiosity within him. It’s when he impulsively follows her that fate, or perhaps a misplaced backpack, intervenes, revealing a book bearing his own name and an older version of his face on the cover – the undeniable proof that Esi is a time traveler from a future he can scarcely imagine.

Joe Greene: From Mediocre Poet to a Crossroads

The revelation of the book confirms Joe’s wildest suspicions: Esi is indeed a time traveler, and not just any tourist. As he soon learns, she’s part of a time-travel tour group from a future where Joe Greene is revered as a literary icon, a Shakespeare of his era. Their mission is apparently to observe this pivotal period in his life. However, Esi’s presence carries a crucial purpose, one she initially keeps hidden from Joe: to ensure his destined path unfolds without deviation. This destiny, it turns out, hinges on his relationship with Diana, a strikingly beautiful and aspiring actress also studying at Cambridge. Diana is meant to be his muse, the inspiration behind the love poems that will solidify his legendary status. Esi’s accidental interaction with Joe has thrown a wrench into this carefully orchestrated timeline, creating a ripple effect that could jeopardize the very future she comes from as well as his own.

Esi: A Time Traveler Caught Between Duty and Desire

Despite the inherent risk of their continued interaction, Esi finds herself in a precarious position. To salvage the timeline and ensure Joe’s destined literary greatness, she feels compelled to nudge him toward Diana. Nonetheless, Joe’s natural awkwardness around women, particularly one as seemingly unattainable as the gorgeous and confident Diana, presents a huge hurdle. What follows is a series of often humorous and slightly painful attempts by Joe to win Diana’s attention, with Esi acting as an unlikely and somewhat reluctant coach. From offering advice on conversation starters to even planning a makeover to improve his appearance, Esi invests herself in a mission that increasingly clashes with her growing feelings for the very man she’s trying to push toward another.

Ironically, the more time Esi spends coaching Joe, the more their own connection deepens. What begins as a strategic maneuver evolves into genuine camaraderie, fueled by shared laughter, late-night conversations, and a mutual understanding that will outshine their vastly different origins.

Esi discovers a sharp wit and hidden depths beneath Joe’s initial awkwardness, while Joe finds himself drawn to Esi’s intelligence, her unconventional perspective, and the unexpected comfort he feels in her presence. The carefully constructed facade of their interactions begins to crumble, revealing genuine affection that neither anticipated. The more they learn about each other, the more Joe realizes he shares a deeper intellectual and emotional connection with Esi than with the seemingly perfect Diana, making the prospect of a future with the aspiring actress feel increasingly hollow.

Destiny vs. Free Will: The Heart’s Rebellion

At its heart of this review, Love and Other Paradoxes grapples with the timeless question of destiny versus free will. Joe Greene’s destined future as a celebrated poet, inspired by Diana, is the seemingly unalterable timeline Esi was tasked to protect. Yet, the unexpected and undeniable attachment between Joe and Esi throws this predetermined path into chaos. Their growing feelings suggest that human connection and individual choice might hold a power beyond the obstacles of time itself.

Whether Joe’s literary greatness is solely due to his relationship with Diana, or if his experiences and emotional growth with Esi could lead to an equally significant, nevertheless altered, future is what this magical realism novel explores. The tension arises from the reader (and the characters) questioning whether they are merely pigeonholed by of fate or if they really can forge their own destinies, even if it means defying the established order of time.

Final Thoughts on This Love and Other Paradoxes Review

In this review of Love and Other Paradoxes, I found it to be more than just a time-travel romance; it’s a poignant exploration of the power of human connection in the face of seemingly insurmountable odds. Catriona Silvey wonderfully weaves together the complexities of temporal mechanics with the deeply relatable emotions of love, longing, and the courage to defy expectations. Joe’s eventual choice, driven by the undeniable pull of his heart, powerfully illustrates the idea that destiny might not always be a fixed point, and that sometimes, the most extraordinary futures are the ones we choose for ourselves. This enchanting romance novel will make you smile and feel good while also prompting reflection on the delicate balance between fate and free will, and the transformative power of a love that goes beyond time.

Thanks to Harper Collins for this #gifted book for this review.