8 Small US Islands With Surprisingly Big Holiday Traditions – Idyllic Pursuit

We may earn money or products from the companies mentioned in this post. This means if you click on the link and purchase the item, I will receive a small commission at no extra cost to you … you’re just helping re-supply our family’s travel fund.

Holiday traditions often feel larger in places where communities are smaller and more isolated. On US islands, seasonal celebrations tend to grow deeper rather than broader, shaped by weather, ferry schedules, limited resources, and shared history. These islands may look quiet on a map, but during the holidays they host rituals, festivals, and community events that rival much larger cities. From maritime Santas to Dickens-style street takeovers, these eight islands prove that scale has very little to do with spirit.

1. Mackinac Island, Michigan

With just around 580 year-round residents and zero cars, Mackinac Island turns Christmas into a fully immersive Victorian scene. Holiday festivities peak in early December with the annual Christmas Bazaar, tree-lighting, and horse-drawn carriage parades through downtown. Historic hotels invest heavily, often spending $40,000–$60,000 each on period-accurate décor and lighting. Winter ferry tickets average $32 round-trip, while holiday room rates drop to $180–$250 per night, making it one of the few affordable seasons to visit. Nearly 90% of businesses participate, creating a town-wide celebration that feels staged yet deeply sincere.

2. Ocracoke Island, North Carolina

Ocracoke Island, home to roughly 675 full-time residents, hosts one of the most unusual Christmas traditions in the US. “Old Buck,” the island’s local Santa figure, arrives by boat rather than sleigh, reflecting the island’s maritime roots. Holiday events center around the waterfront, with decorated fishing vessels and community seafood feasts costing about $25 per plate. Winter ferry crossings average $15 per vehicle, but weather cancellations add to the island’s isolation. Locals estimate over 70% of residents attend holiday gatherings, turning Christmas into a rare moment when nearly the entire island comes together.

3. San Juan Island, Washington

San Juan Island’s holiday season revolves around its famous Christmas Ship Festival, where illuminated boats circle the harbor while choirs sing from the decks. With a population near 8,600, participation is unusually high for a rural island. Private boat owners spend an average of $1,200–$2,000 decorating vessels each year. Shore-side events are free, while ferry fares from the mainland cost about $17 per adult. Local shops report winter sales increases of 18–22% during festival weeks, proving that this quiet island briefly becomes a cultural hub without losing its calm identity.

4. Bald Head Island, North Carolina

Accessible only by ferry, Bald Head Island has around 300 permanent residents, yet hosts a holiday season that feels far larger. Cars are banned, so residents decorate golf carts as sleighs for island-wide parades. The Maritime Christmas weekend includes lighthouse tours priced at $12 per person, wreath-making workshops, and coastal caroling. Ferry tickets cost roughly $24 round-trip, while holiday rentals drop to $220–$300 per night. Despite a high number of seasonal homes, locals estimate nearly 80% occupancy during December events, creating a rare sense of unity on the island.

5. Block Island, Rhode Island

Block Island’s winter population shrinks to about 1,000 residents, but its holiday traditions intensify rather than fade. The annual Holiday Stroll keeps shops open late, with live music and harbor bonfires funded by local donations averaging $10–$20 per person. Ferry tickets in winter cost approximately $29 round-trip, and hotel rates fall below $160 per night, attracting cold-weather visitors. The New Year’s Day plunge draws over 300 participants, raising thousands for local causes. Isolation and harsh weather turn the holidays into a bonding exercise as much as a celebration.

6. Amelia Island, Florida

Amelia Island blends Southern charm with Victorian flair during its Dickens on Centre festival. With a population near 13,000, the island hosts over 50,000 visitors across the holiday weekend. Local businesses collectively spend an estimated $500,000 on costumes, stage setups, and décor. Entry is free, but dining and shopping average $75–$120 per visitor. Hotel rates rise modestly to $210–$280 per night, far less than comparable mainland festivals. Nearly every shop and restaurant participates, transforming the historic district into a living period drama each December.

7. Catalina Island, California

Despite sitting just 22 miles from Los Angeles, Catalina Island preserves surprisingly intimate holiday traditions. Avalon’s annual boat parade features over 30 decorated vessels, with owners spending roughly $800–$1,500 per boat. The island’s population of about 4,000 supports tree-lightings, seaside services, and handmade ornament exchanges. Ferry tickets average $83 round-trip, keeping crowds manageable. Winter hotel rates drop to $190–$240 per night, encouraging longer stays. Reflections of lights across the harbor create a festive atmosphere that feels disconnected from mainland California entirely.

8. Orcas Island, Washington

Orcas Island, home to roughly 2,300 residents, approaches the holidays with a creative, almost spiritual intensity. Events blend Christmas with solstice rituals, craft fairs, and storytelling nights. Local artisans report earning 30–40% of their annual income during the holiday season, with handmade gifts averaging $45–$120. Ferry fares cost around $17 per adult, while winter lodging averages $175–$230 per night. Nearly 65% of residents attend communal events, reinforcing the island’s reputation for deeply personal, locally driven celebrations rooted in nature and tradition.

Other Blog Posts You Might Enjoy