11 Hidden Islands in the U.S. You Can Actually Visit Without Crowds – Author Kathy Haan

We may earn money or products from the companies mentioned in this post. This means if you click on the link and purchase the item, I will receive a small commission at no extra cost to you … you’re just helping re-supply our family’s travel fund.

Tired of the usual tourist traps? The U.S. offers a treasure trove of secluded islands perfect for travelers seeking peace, adventure, and authentic local life without the crowds. From Georgia’s wild Cumberland Island with its empty beaches and roaming horses, to Washington’s tranquil Whidbey and Lopez Islands with charming small towns and quiet coves, these hidden gems promise pristine nature and solitude. Discover 11 such islands where you can truly disconnect and explore a quieter America.

1. Isle Royale, Michigan – A Wilderness Escape

Isle Royale, nestled in the cold waters of Lake Superior, stands as a sanctuary for nature enthusiasts. This UNESCO International Biosphere Reserve is one of the least-visited national parks in the contiguous United States, accessible only by boat or seaplane. Its isolation ensures a tranquil environment, making it ideal for hiking, kayaking, and observing wildlife like moose and wolves in their natural habitat. With over 400 smaller islands surrounding it, Isle Royale offers a unique blend of solitude and adventure. Visitors can explore its dense forests, rugged shorelines, and pristine waters, all while enjoying the serenity that comes with limited human presence. For those seeking a true wilderness experience, Isle Royale provides an unparalleled opportunity to connect with nature.

2. Admiralty Island, Alaska – The Fortress of the Bears

Admiralty Island, located in Southeast Alaska, is a haven for wildlife enthusiasts and adventure seekers. Home to the highest density of brown bears in North America, the island offers a rare glimpse into the lives of these majestic creatures. Accessible only by boat or seaplane, Admiralty Island remains largely untouched, preserving its natural beauty and providing a sanctuary for various wildlife species. Visitors can embark on guided tours to observe bears in their natural habitat, hike through lush forests, and explore the island’s rugged coastline. The island’s remote location ensures a peaceful retreat, far from the hustle and bustle of urban life. For those seeking an immersive wildlife experience, Admiralty Island stands as a testament to Alaska’s untamed wilderness.

3. San Miguel Island, California – The Wild West of the Channel Islands

San Miguel Island, part of California’s Channel Islands National Park, offers a raw and rugged landscape for those willing to venture off the beaten path. Accessible only by boat, the island is known for its dramatic cliffs, diverse wildlife, and rich history. Visitors can explore the island’s historic lighthouse, hike its challenging trails, and observe native species such as sea lions and a variety of seabirds. The island’s isolation and limited access ensure a peaceful environment, making it a perfect destination for nature lovers and history enthusiasts alike. Camping opportunities allow visitors to immerse themselves fully in the island’s natural beauty. San Miguel Island provides a unique opportunity to experience California’s coastal wilderness in its most pristine form.

4. Cumberland Island, Georgia -Wild Horses and Historic Ruins

Cumberland Island, Georgia’s southernmost barrier island, offers a unique blend of natural beauty and historical intrigue. Accessible only by ferry, the island is renowned for its wild horses that roam freely along its pristine beaches. Visitors can explore the ruins of the Carnegie family’s mansion, hike through maritime forests, and camp under the stars. The island’s rich history includes its use as a retreat for the wealthy in the early 20th century, leaving behind architectural remnants that add to its charm. With no cars allowed and limited development, Cumberland Island provides a tranquil escape into nature and history. Its diverse ecosystems, ranging from salt marshes to dense forests, make it a haven for wildlife and a paradise for outdoor enthusiasts.

5. Tangier Island, Virginia – A Step Back in Time

Tangier Island, located in the Chesapeake Bay, offers a rare glimpse into a way of life that has remained largely unchanged for centuries. Accessible only by boat, the island’s residents speak with a distinctive accent and maintain traditions that date back to the 17th century. Visitors can explore the island’s quiet streets by bicycle, sample fresh seafood, and learn about its rich history at local museums. The island’s isolation has preserved its unique culture and way of life, making it a fascinating destination for those interested in history and anthropology. Tangier Island’s charm lies in its simplicity and the warmth of its community, offering a peaceful retreat from modern life.

6. Beaver Island, Michigan – The Emerald Isle of the Great Lakes

Beaver Island, situated in Lake Michigan, is a tranquil retreat known for its Irish heritage and natural beauty. Accessible by ferry or small aircraft, the island boasts sandy beaches, dense forests, and a rich history that includes its settlement by Irish immigrants in the 19th century. Visitors can explore the island’s lighthouses, hike its scenic trails, and enjoy local cuisine at family-owned restaurants. The island’s relaxed pace and friendly community make it an ideal destination for those seeking a peaceful getaway. Beaver Island’s charm lies in its blend of cultural heritage and natural beauty, offering a unique experience in the heart of the Great Lakes.

7. Great Diamond Island, Maine – A Quiet Retreat Near Portland

Great Diamond Island, located just a short ferry ride from Portland, Maine, offers a serene escape from the city’s hustle and bustle. With only about 77 residents, the island is free from cars and commercial development, providing a peaceful environment for relaxation. Visitors can explore the island’s historic sites, including Fort McKinley, hike its scenic trails, and enjoy waterfront dining at local eateries. The island’s small size and limited amenities encourage visitors to slow down and appreciate its natural beauty. Great Diamond Island’s proximity to Portland allows for easy access while maintaining its tranquil charm.

8. Cuttyhunk Island, Massachusetts – A Secluded New England Gem

Cuttyhunk Island, the southernmost of Massachusetts’ Elizabeth Islands, offers a peaceful retreat with stunning views and a rich history. Accessible by ferry, the island is known for its quiet beaches, historic lighthouse, and small fishing community. Visitors can explore the island’s trails, enjoy fresh seafood at local restaurants, and learn about its history at the Cuttyhunk Historical Society. The island’s lack of commercial development and limited accommodations ensure a tranquil experience. Cuttyhunk Island’s charm lies in its simplicity and the beauty of its natural surroundings.

9. Daufuskie Island, South Carolina – A Step Back in Time

Daufuskie Island, located between Hilton Head Island and Savannah, offers a unique blend of history and natural beauty. Accessible only by boat, the island is known for its charming dirt roads, historic sites, and vibrant arts community. Visitors can explore the island’s historic homes, visit local art galleries, and enjoy fresh seafood at waterfront restaurants. The island’s isolation has preserved its unique culture and way of life, making it a fascinating destination for those interested in history and art. Daufuskie Island’s charm lies in its blend of history, art, and natural beauty, offering a peaceful retreat from modern life.

10. Shell Key Preserve, Florida – A Pristine Barrier Island

Shell Key Preserve, located between the Gulf of Mexico and Tampa Bay, is a rare undeveloped barrier island offering a pristine natural retreat. Accessible only by boat, kayak, or authorized ferry, the island is ideal for swimming, shelling, birding, and primitive camping with a permit. Visitors must come prepared, as there are no restrooms or drinking water on the island, and both pets and alcohol are prohibited to protect the sensitive ecosystem. The island’s clear waters, abundant marine life, and stunning sunsets make it a popular destination for nature lovers. Shell Key Preserve’s isolation ensures a peaceful environment, allowing visitors to connect with nature in its most unspoiled form.

11. Molokai, Hawaii – The Most Hawaiian Island

Molokai, often referred to as the “Most Hawaiian Island,” offers an authentic Hawaiian experience without the crowds. Known for its rich cultural heritage and natural beauty, the island is home to the Kalaupapa National Historical Park, which preserves the history of the leprosy settlement. Visitors can explore the island’s pristine beaches, hike its scenic trails, and learn about its history and culture at local museums. Molokai’s commitment to preserving its traditions and environment ensures an authentic and peaceful experience for visitors.

​

Other Blog Posts You Might Enjoy